Tuesday, December 8, 2009

5. Crucible pg. 67-81

Mary Warren: "I cannot charge murder on Abigail. [...] She'll kill me for sayin' that! Abby'll charge lechery on you, Mr. Proctor. [...] She'll ruin you with it, I know she will" (80).

Proctor is outraged when Cheever comes to take Elizabeth away. Proctor tries to keep Elizabeth from going, showing that he really does care about her. When Abigail approached him in the previous readings, he told her not to speak ill of Elizabeth and defended her. Whatever happened with Abigail has passed and he regrets it: "I will cut my hand off before I'll ever reach for you again" (23). Proctor does not care if Abigail accuses him of lechery because he is more concerned about Elizabeth: "Good. Then [Abagail's] saintliness is done with. We will slide together into our pit; you will tell the court what you know" (80). He could also be taking the matter in his own hands because he is sick of "children [...] jangling the keys of the kingdom, and common vengeance [writing] the law" (77). Proctor represents the strength the other male characters lack in the play. He speaks reasonably and is not afraid of what people think of him.


Proctor: "You are a coward! Though you be ordained in God's own tears, you are a coward now" (79).

Hale's uncertainty has increased, but he is not willing to speak up. He is just as scared as the innocent people who need to claim they were once witches in order to save their lives. Hale is a reverend who is not doing his job. If he has been ordained in the light of God, there is no need to be afraid, or else this shows Hale has doubt in Him. Hale feels guilty when Elizabeth is taken away. There would be no guilt if he agreed that Elizabeth was a witch. Cheever and Herrick seem to be working for Abigail. If she claims somebody is a witch, they hunt that person down without a question. Nobody sees the absurdity of teenage girls empowering the court.

4. Crucible pg. 49- 60

Elizabeth: "John- grant me this. You have a faulty understanding of young girls. There is a promise made in any bed-" (61).

After seven months, Elizabeth still holds Proctor's mistake against him. Even though he admitted to adultery, she has a tough time forgiving him and simply forgetting about it. Elizabeth has reason to despise Abigail, but her emotions cannot interfere with reason. Proctor explains the difficulty of telling the court Abigail is a fraud, but Elizabeth is more concerned that he was alone with her when he found this out: "You were alone with [Abigail]?" (53). Proctor wants Elizabeth to appreciate his honesty and notice the effort he makes to compensate for his misbehavior: "I mean to please you" (50). Knowing a spouse has cheated on you is not easy to forget, but under the circumstances of their strict community and Christian relationship, she has no choice but to deal with it. The deed was committed; now, Elizabeth must move on.


Elizabeth: "[Abigail] thinks to kill me, then take my place" (61).

Unfortunately, Elizabeth is right when she believes Abigail wants to kill her: "[Abigail] drank a charm to kill John Proctor's wife! [Abigail] drank a charm to kill Goody Proctor!" (19). Since Abigail is obsessed with Proctor, she will do anything to get Elizabeth away from him. Abigail also has a strong influence in the court, so Elizabeth needs to be careful: "Where [Abigail] walks the crowd will part like the sea for Israel" (52-53). In other words, it is necessary for Abigail to be stopped before she causes anymore harm to innocent people like Elizabeth.

Pride and Prejudice Essay

Marriage unifies two people into one being, but there are a multitude of reasons for why two people marry. People often make the mistake of marrying a person for their wealth, rather than valuing their partner’s qualities. Others make the decision to marry based on practicality, without care for commitment. The reason that truly justifies a marriage is when two people are blissfully in love and mutually make the decision to spend the rest of their lives together. In a love marriage, nobody benefits more than the other, and there is a growing depth to the relationship, which makes love the most favorable basis for marriage.
In Pride and Prejudice, the characters reveal three types of marital motives through differing relationships. Mr. Wickham is first introduced as a man to die for, with charming good looks and personality. After attracting Elizabeth Bennet, Mr. Wickham immediately shifts his interest to Miss King when he finds out she inherited a large sum of money: “[Mr. Wickham] paid [Miss King] not the smallest attention, till her grandfather’s death made her mistress of this fortune” (Austen 118). Mr. Wickham suddenly becomes interested in Miss King because he wants her wealth, which reveals his mercenary intentions. Unfortunately, this does not stop Mr. Wickham from acquiring enough money to get out of his debts: “Wickham still cherished the hope of more effectually making his fortune by marriage” (245). As the novel continues, he makes a swift move onto the docile heart of Lydia Bennet. Initially, Mr. Wickham used Lydia as an excuse to leave the militia. When Mr. Darcy asked Mr. Wickham if he was interested in marrying Lydia, “[Mr. Darcy] easily learnt, [marrying Lydia] had never been [Mr. Wickham’s] design” (245). Mr. Darcy convinced Mr. Wickham to marry Lydia, because running away without a cause would put more shame upon Mr. Wickham and the Bennet family. Mr. Wickham’s motive stayed resolute, and he acquired the money for his debt from Mr. Darcy. The greed of Mr. Wickham still continued after his marriage with Lydia: “[Mr. Wickham] not wholly without hope that Darcy might yet be prevailed on to make his fortune” (296). Mr. Wickham wanted more money, showing no gratitude for Mr. Darcy’s help.
Mr. Wickham’s first attempt of acquiring wealth must not be forgotten. He charmed the innocent heart of Miss Darcy into almost eloping with him: “Mr. Wickham’s chief object was unquestionably my sister’s fortune” (155). Mr. Wickham purported his love for Miss Darcy and broke her heart with no remorse. A mercenary marriage benefits one partner through the other’s wealth; in this case, Mr. Wickham would have been the benefactor of all three of these ladies. Mr. Wickham managed to reach his goal when he married Lydia.
A mercenary marriage does not unite two people into one being; it unites one person with the other’s wealth. A person with mercenary interests is using the means of marriage for their own personal advantages, not pursuing what the true meaning of marriage is: love. A person marries another for the love of their partner, not the love of their partner’s money. Mr. Wickham did not love Elizabeth, Miss King, Lydia, or Miss Darcy. Even as a married man, his love for Lydia withered away: “His affection for [Lydia] soon sunk into indifference” (296). The amount of wealth one shares with their partner should not affect the love that is shared between them. Mr. Wickham left Elizabeth and the other women ignorantly without considering their feelings. In the end, Wickham is not happy with his relationship, which clearly shows that money is one of the least favorable reasons for marriage.
Mr.Collins took a practical approach to marriage when he came to Longbourn. In order to find a wife, Mr. Collins went down the line of Bennet daughters. Since Jane was taken by Mr. Bingley, he proposed to Elizabeth. In his proposal, he explained his motives for marriage, which solely benefited himself: “I think it is a right thing for every clergyman […] to set the example of matrimony in his parish. […] I am convinced it will add very greatly to my happiness. […] It is the noble advice […] of [my] patroness” (81). Mr. and Mrs. Bennet wanted one of their daughters to marry Mr. Collins in order to keep the Bennet land among family. Since Mr. Collins was to entail the land after Mr. Bennet’s death, it made sense for Elizabeth to marry him. Besides that, Mr. Collins did not love Elizabeth. He claims to hold “violence of […] affection” (81) for her, yet marries Charlotte Lucas within a day of Elizabeth’s rejection.
A practical approach to marriage was also taken by Charlotte Lucas when she decided to marry Mr. Collins. Charlotte listed the necessities she believed would make her happy in order to justify her marriage with him: “I ask only a comfortable home; and considering Mr. Collins’s character, connections, and situation in life, I am convinced that my chance of happiness with him is as fair, as most people can boast on entering the marriage state” (96). This prudent marriage benefits not only Charlotte with a home and a nice living, but also Mr. Collins with a wife. This list of benefits only supply satisfaction and not true happiness, something a love marriage would provide.
The relationship between Charlotte and Mr. Collins had no depth, unlike a love marriage. Both characters were incapable of showing the other any affection because there was no physical attraction to begin with. Charlotte and Mr. Collins shared neutral feelings and showed no genuine care for each other. They did not marry because they loved one another; they married for their own benefits. Similarly to a mercenary marriage, a prudent marriage is also taking advantage of matrimony. In this case, instead of two people uniting as one being, Charlotte and Mr. Collins united for their own personal needs.
As for Jane and Bingley, they married with a focus on love and affection. The Bennet family needed to marry their first daughter; thus, Jane was introduced to Mr. Bingley. Jane and Mr. Bingley were two optimistic people who found joy being together. When Mr. Bingley left Longbourn, Jane was heartbroken and tried convincing herself to forget about Mr. Bingley: “The first wish of my heart […] is never more to be in company with [Mr. Bingley] […] Let me never see [him] again!” (257). After Mr. Darcy brought Mr. Bingley back, it did not take long for Jane and Mr. Bingley to rekindle their relationship. After a year without communication, Jane and Mr. Bingley’s love remained strong. Distance did not stop the love between the two characters, showing the powerful affect love can have on a person.
Elizabeth and Mr. Darcy took a completely opposite route to their marriage. Mr. Darcy’s comment on Elizabeth’s appearance shifted their relationship towards disaster: “[Elizabeth] is tolerable; but not handsome enough to tempt me” (7). From that point, Elizabeth kept a grudge towards Mr. Darcy and judged him on his first impression: “[Mr. Darcy’s] character was decided. He was the proudest, most disagreeable man in the world” (7). Elizabeth held her grudge and rejected Mr. Darcy’s proposal, but she reconsidered her feelings when he paid for Lydia’s wedding: “[Elizabeth’s] heart did whisper, that [Mr. Darcy] had done it for her” (248). Mr. Darcy went out of his way to help Elizabeth’s family even though he despised Mr. Wickham and had “neither regard nor esteem” (248) for Lydia. Mr. Darcy hindered his wealth and status, also sacrificing the respect of his aunt to marry Elizabeth. He did not care about the dishonor that would come to his name if he married her because he loved Elizabeth passionately.
Mr. Darcy did not stop trying to win Elizabeth’s love even though she rejected him: “I had not known you a month before I felt that you were the last man in the world whom I could ever be prevailed to marry” (148). After realizing her idiocy, Elizabeth expected Mr. Darcy to court her yet again. She did not even believe the things Mr. Darcy said to her in his proposal and continued to doubt them: “A man who has once been refused! How could I ever be foolish enough to expect a renewal of his love?” (260). Mr. Darcy fixed the flaws Elizabeth saw in him and took the time to write her a letter, justifying his actions with Mr. Bingley and Mr. Wickham. Mr. Darcy went through many obstacles to achieve Elizabeth’s love. She opened her eyes and eliminated her prejudice towards him to see the true gentleman he really was: “I am the happiest creature in the world. Perhaps other people have said so before, but no one with such justice. I am happier than Jane; she only smiles, I laugh” (293).
Wealth and practicality of a marriage are overpowered by love. Mr. Bingley and Mr. Darcy’s love for their wives was more important than the dishonor of their status. When two people unite as one being, materialistic objects are worthless. It is the person, and solely the qualities of that person, which make one fall in love with another and wish to marry. In Pride and Prejudice, love marriage brought the most happiness to the characters, whereas the growth of the mercenary and prudent marriages was limited. Love challenged Mr. Bingley, Mr. Darcy, and the Bennet sisters, but all four characters overcame many obstacles for the love of their partner. A love marriage promoted the unity of two people through true love, whereas mercenary and prudent marriages are held as a means to an end. In a love marriage, there is no end, simply never ending growth.

Friday, December 4, 2009

3.Crucible pg. 31-49

Quote 1: "I know it, sir, I sent my child-she [Ruth] should learn from Tituba who murdered her sisters" (38).

Mrs. Putnam is also an instigator, just like her husband, but she is digging a hole for herself towards being the reason for her daughter's craziness or in other words, witchcraft. She knew sending Ruth, her own child, to communicate with the dead was a sinful thing to do. The two times Mrs. Putnam mentions she sent Ruth to the forest, she is given the same surprised response from two different characters: "Goody Ann! You sent a child to conjure up up he dead?" (39). It is a shocking thing to do, especially sending your own child to do something that is considered sinful. If Mrs. Putnam wanted to learn something about her deceased babies, she should have gone to Tituba, not sent her daughter. It seems like the only reason for why she would put her daughter's life at risk is to protect her own reputation from being called a witch. Mrs. Putnam defends herself to justify it was an acceptable thing to do by attempting to win sympathy for the loss of her seven babies. Mrs. Putnam should not be complaining about why Ruth is acting strange. Ruth was sent to the forest by her. It does not matter what the reasons are, entering the forest is crossing the limits, which everybody knows. Having a child do it is worse. Somebody could easily point a finger at Mrs. Putnam and accuse her of being the cause of her daughter's strange behavior. This would be a change because Mr. and Mrs.Putnam are usually the ones to instigate an accusation against somebody else or blame others for the use of witchcraft.

Quote 2: "No man has ever been blamed for so much [...] He [Giles Corey] didn't give a hoot for public opinion" (40).

Giles Corey is the only character in the play so far that does not hold his reputation as a priority. It does not matter to Corey what people think of him. When Parris is introduced, it is clear that his reputation as a minister is more important to him than the fact his daughter is not feeling well. The Putnam couple is quick to blame others for witchcraft, pushing away any accusations that could possibly come their way, leaving them with a clean slate. Abigail Williams claims to be a good soul, but the audience knows very well that she is a conniving minx. Corey has understood that every member in society will accuse another for strange things happening to them. He is so used to accusations, that it does not shock him when somebody thinks he is the reason for their unfortunate event: "It suggests to the mind that the trouble be among us all these years. Think on it. Wherefore is everybody suing everybody else? [...] I have been six time in court this year-" (31). Corey takes a more logical perspective on this. Instead of blaming others for being witches, he states that witchcraft seems to be an ongoing issue for many years and needs to be eliminated. Since witchcraft is conflicting with the characters' daily lives, everybody is quick to point a finger at somebody else they are not on good terms with, assuming it was their fault. Being one of the eldest characters, Corey has had a fair share of hearing about witchcraft.

Wednesday, December 2, 2009

P&P Assignment #2- Lady Catherine

Lady Catherine

Many battled for social supremacy during the time period of Pride and Prejudice. The high class of society were revered and known to be the poised and the privileged. Jane Austen uses Lady Catherine as a representation of a member from the elite class gone wrong.

Mr. Darcy and Lady Catherine were from the same social status, but were polar opposites. Lady Catherine showed her arrogance by boasting the good she had done to Elizabeth and her other guests: “It is wonderful how many families I have been the means of supplying [...] I am always glad to get a young person well placed out” (Austen 127). On the other hand, Elizabeth heard of the virtuous deeds Mr. Darcy did from his own servant: “He was always the sweetest-tempered, most generous-hearted, boy in the world” (188). Not once did Mr. Darcy boast about how charitable he was and what he had done to help society. He was humble, unlike his pompous aunt. A genuine upperclassman like Mr. Darcy did not need to flaunt his goodness; however, Lady Catherine found a need to express how generous she was when many were already aware of her wealth.

Mr. Darcy treated people below him with the same respect he treated upperclassmen, whereas Lady Catherine excessively averred the distinction in status between herself and those of lower classes. She spoke to Elizabeth in an impertinent manner, belittling the parenting skills of her mother: “I suppose you had no opportunity. Your mother should have taken you to town every spring for the benefit of masters” (127). Lady Catherine had no right to involve herself in the Bennet family’s private affairs. In contrast, when Mr. Darcy met the Gardiners at Pemberley, he conversed with them amiably: “I was never more surprised than by his behavior to us. It was more than civil; it was really attentive; and there was no necessity for such attention” (195). When Mr. Darcy and Lady Catherine interacted with members of the lower class, Mr. Darcy impressed the Gardiners who expected him to act arrogantly, unlike Lady Catherine, who insulted Elizabeth, giving her a terrible first impression. Mr. Darcy was courteous to his guests. He did not need to present his high status by acting superior to them; however, Lady Catherine not only showed her supremacy, but also her discourtesy of lower classes.

With regards to acts of civility, Lady Catherine did not know how to show class. Although Mr. Darcy made a mistake in breaking up Bingley and Jane, he had good intentions in mind. He convinced Bingley out of marrying Jane because he thought she did not care for Bingley. Lady Catherine wanted to break up Mr. Darcy and Elizabeth’s potential relationship to save Mr. Darcy from the dishonor of marrying a lowerclassman. Instead of talking Mr. Darcy out of it, Lady Catherine stormed into the Bennet household and rudely attempted to convince Elizabeth not to marry Mr. Darcy: “When the wishes of both sisters would be accomplished, in their marriage, to be prevented by a young woman of inferior birth, of no importance in the world, and wholly unallied to the family!” (271). Lady Catherine had the audacity to go to the Bennet household and affront Elizabeth in her own home. One would not expect a woman of such elite status to degrade a young woman of a lower class in such a manner.

Jane Austen creates the allusion that an elitist is expected to be generous, honorable, and virtuous. Mr. Darcy fits this description of the ideal elitist, whereas Lady Catherine puts the class to shame. Austen is telling her audience that title and money should not dictate class structure; however, in reality, a person’s status and wealth will always separate one person from another. Lady Catherine only achieved a high social status because she married into a wealthy family, which gave her a sense of authority over the lower classes. The means of working hard to achieve an honorable position was the least of concerns.

Bibliography:

Austen, Jane. Pride and Prejudice. New York: Oxford University Press Inc., 1970.

2. Crucible pg. 8-30

Quote 1: "It is not surprising to find that so many accusations against people are in the handwriting of Thomas Putnam, or that his name is so often used as a witness corroborating the supernatural testimony, or that his daughter led the crying-out at the most opportune junctures of the trials" (15).

Thomas Putnam seems to be an instigator towards witchcraft. He maintains his reputation and position by putting other people's lives at stake and uses references that allude to possible witchcraft in order to raise awareness that somebody is using it: "That is a notorious sign of witchcraft afoot, Goody Nurse, a prodigious sign!" (25). Putnam tries to persuade Parris that he should tell the village about the witchcraft going on when he knows this will destroy Parris's position in society, especially because Parris is a reverend and strange things should not be happening in his house of all places: "Let your enemies make of it what they will, you cannot blink it more" (16). As long as Mr. Putnam is not being negatively affected, it does not matter to him what occurs. His presence in the village seems to focus a lot on himself.


Quote 2: "Let either of you breathe a word, or the edge of a word, about the other things, and I will come to you in the black of some terrible night and I will bring you a pointy reckoning that will shudder you. And you know I can do it" (20).

Abigail Williams turns out to be somewhat of a lunatic and will definitely be pinned for being a witch some time in the book. She sounds innocent when she speaks to Parris, but when she converses with other peers, we hear more of her inappropriate deeds she is hiding. Abigail starts off saying she only danced in the forest, but then it is later revealed that she also drank blood in order to kill Goody Proctor and had some sort of an affair with her husband. Considering how Parris took Abigail into his home just like a daughter, this is not a way she should be repaying him for his hospitality. The things she does will cause Parris, herself, and possibly Betty to be suspected as witches. If one goes down, then the others are at risk. The characters introduced so far all have some sort of tension between each other and disagree with at least one other person very often. They need to be careful what is said or else it will not be difficult to accuse somebody of saying something sinful, and have that person be penalized for it. It is hard living in such a society where nobody can be trusted.

Sunday, November 29, 2009

Character Analysis #2: Mr. Collins

Mr. Collins

Mr. Collins is a sycophant who focuses solely on himself and his own well-being.

Mr. Collins is a man who puts his reputation above all other obligations. He looks up to the wealthy Lady Catherine for advice and recommendations. His priority is to fulfill the standards of one with commendable social status and likewise, regards himself as a very respectable person. When Mr. Collins proposes to Elizabeth, he gives three distinct reasons for why he should marry her, which all regard to his happiness and satisfaction. After she rejects him, he believes something is wrong with her, instead of reflecting on what his faults may be: “It is usual with young ladies to reject the addresses of the man whom they secretly mean to accept” (82). Mr. Collins also openly expresses his relief for not marrying into the Bennet family due to the dishonor it would have caused him when he found out that Lydia and Mr. Wickham almost eloped: “This consideration leads me moreover to reflect with augmented satisfaction on a certain event of last November, for had it been otherwise, I must have been involved in all your sorrow and disgrace” (225). In other words, Mr. Collins is a follower who looks out for his own beneficence.

Mr. Collins is a leech who only benefits itself by sucking blood. When a leech is present, it satisfies solely itself, unaware of the pain it causes to its victim. Likewise, Mr. Collins is inconsiderate and watches out for himself without realizing he is insulting others.

Mr. Collins is like Sarah Palin who came across as a very artificial person and always tried to suck up to America in search for its approval.